Choosing the Right Fence Style: Shadow Box, Privacy, or Board-on-Board

Adam

Adam Hatley

13 February, 2025

Choosing the Right Fence Style: Shadow Box, Privacy, or Board-on-Board

Get Your Free Estimate

All Fields Required

Get Your Free Estimate

All Fields Required

"*" indicates required fields

*
SMS Text
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Selecting the perfect fence style is about more than just aesthetics—it’s about meeting your unique needs. Whether you’re prioritizing privacy, airflow, durability, or visual appeal, different styles offer distinct benefits to suit your home and lifestyle.

1. Shadow Box Fence

A shadow box fence features alternating pickets on either side of the fence rails, creating a semi-private design. It blends functionality and aesthetics, allowing airflow and light while maintaining moderate privacy.

shadowbox wood fence in backyard

Key Benefits:

  • Ideal for Shared Property Lines – The identical appearance on both sides makes it a great option for neighbors splitting costs.
  • Enhanced Airflow – The gaps between pickets allow wind to pass through, reducing resistance and minimizing damage in high-wind areas.
  • Visually Appealing – The alternating pickets create depth and an elegant shadowing effect.
  • Moderate Privacy – Offers partial screening without fully blocking views.

Best Suited For:

  • Homes in breezy areas
  • Fences shared with neighbors
  • Decorative fencing that balances privacy and design

2. Privacy Fence

A privacy fence is a solid panel designed to completely block views, providing a secluded and secure outdoor space. Typically made from wood, vinyl, or composite materials, it is a timeless choice for true privacy.

Wood and brick privacy fence

Key Benefits:

  • Full Privacy – Ideal for keeping your yard entirely shielded from neighbors and passersby.
  • Added Security – A tall, solid structure adds an extra layer of protection against intrusions.
  • Noise Reduction – Helps absorb noise from traffic, neighbors, or nearby activity.
  • Shield from the Elements – Offers protection from strong winds and extensive sun exposure.

Best Suited For:

  • Backyards needing complete privacy
  • Pool enclosures
  • Homes in busy neighborhoods or near roads

3. Board-on-Board Fence

A board-on-board fence elevates the traditional privacy fence with overlapping vertical boards. This design ensures no gaps develop as wood naturally shrinks, maximizing longevity and privacy.

A new cedar wood fence with landscaping

Key Benefits:

  • Gap-Free Privacy – The overlapping boards maintain full privacy, even as the wood adjusts over time.
  • Extra Durability – The layered design provides increased strength for better resistance to environmental elements.
  • Upscale Aesthetics – The elegant structure boosts curb appeal with a premium look.
  • Extended Lifespan – Built to withstand harsh weather over time without compromise.

Best Suited For:

  • Homeowners seeking a luxury privacy fence
  • Areas with harsh weather conditions
  • Long-term privacy needs

Compare Fence Styles at a Glance

Style

Privacy Level

Airflow

Durability

Aesthetic Appeal

Best For

Shadow Box

Moderate

High

Medium

Unique & Decorative

Shared fences, windy areas

Privacy

High

Low

Medium

Simple & Functional

Maximum privacy, pool enclosures

Board-on-Board

High

Low

High

Elegant & Premium

Extreme weather, long-lasting use

Find the Perfect Fence for Your Home

Selecting the right fence depends on your priorities—privacy, airflow, durability, or aesthetics. Each style offers unique advantages tailored to different needs and environments.

If you’re unsure which fence style suits your home, consulting with a professional fencing contractor like Top Rail Fence can make all the difference. They’ll guide you based on your location, budget, and preferences to create a fence that perfectly complements your property.

Enhance your outdoor space today with a fence tailored just for you! Reach out to your local Top Rail Fence expert to get started!

Adam Hatley

Adam Hatley, based in Chicago, IL, has over 20 years of experience in the fencing industry. He began building fences at the age of 15 as a summer job, and later founded his own fencing business in Los Angeles, CA. He eventually relocated the business to his hometown, Memphis, TN, where he scaled operations, specializing in fences, decks, and pergolas. An Eagle Scout with extensive construction experience, Adam brings a wealth of expertise to the industry.